Democracy in Peril: Susan Stokes Delivers Stone Lecture

By

Ethan Cooper

The annual Stone Lecture took place last Friday.

The lecture is named after Dr. Ivan B. Stone, formerly the dean of Beloit College and director of Beloit’s World Affairs Center, a position he held for three decades. His foundational work in study abroad and global experiences is honored in the Stone Lecture, drawing scholars of all disciplines, largely focusing on international policy and geopolitics.

This year’s lecturer was Dr. Susan Stokes, Blake Distinguished Service Professor of Political Science and Faculty Chair of the Chicago Center on Democracy at the University of Chicago. She has published a great deal of scholarship on global democracies, specifically in Latin America, and political behavior more broadly. Her accolades include serving as president of the American Political Science Association and co-founding Bright Line Watch, a cadre of political scientists who surveil and report on democratic stability in the United States.

Faculty, students, and community members alike gathered in the Weissberg Auditorium at 7 p.m. Joshua Moore, Senior Director of Global and Immersive Learning, introduced the lecture, and Beth Dougherty, Professor of Political Science, introduced Stokes.

Stokes discussed the rise of liberal optimism in the eighties and nineties, which fell into democratic backsliding in the first quarter of the twenty-first century. She asked two basic questions. “Why is the world experiencing a wave of democratic erosion at this moment? Why now?” and “Why are some countries more prone to seek their democracies a road than others?”

She began the answer by outlining the symptoms of a backsliding democracy. She outlined a laundry list of possible signs. “Your president or prime minister will try to undermine the power and independence of key institutions. He’ll attack the press … He may impose censorship or encourage self-censorship … He’ll attack the courts, saying that they’re full of incompetent judges … he’ll break long-established rules for judicial appointments, increasingly aligning the Supreme Court, or Apex courts, with the executive branch … He’ll use the criminal justice system to go after opponents. He’ll purge the civil service, the bureaucracy, replacing professionals with partisans. He’ll go after civil society organizations or NGOs, trying to economically strangle civil society and the kinds of organizations that he considers to be enemies.”

Next, she analyzed the potential causes, utilizing statistical measures found in her research to back up her claims. She found that, accounting for all details and possible false correlations, unequal wealth distribution is the number one cause of democratic erosion across all countries and regions. “We kept finding one robust feature that we couldn’t get rid of. And that was income inequality. So the more unequal the income distribution of a country, or the more unequal the distribution of wealth in a country, the greater its probability or risk of experiencing democratic erosion.”

She delved into extant mechanisms to combat such backsliding, drawing examples domestically and abroad. One such lever, she said, is legal accountability. “So backsliders, especially once they’re out of power, have sometimes been prosecuted and even removed from public life, from political life.” She used the prosecution of Jair Bolsonaro in Brazil as an example.

Furthermore, she elucidated electoral accountability as another weapon in the civil arsenal to combat democratic erosion. “Just in the past six months, we’ve had three consequential elections, involving three men, and they are Viktor Orbán … The long-serving Prime Minister, 15 years in power, in Hungary … Aleksandar Vučić from Serbia, who just very recently lost … and then Flavio Bolsonaro, the son of Jair Bolsonaro in Brazil.”

She also recommended policies to decrease wealth inequality, as these measures, while potentially costly, could provide necessary democratic backbone to society.

She concluded the talk with an observation on illiberal democracies and autocracies; drawing on the philosophy of Immanuel Kant, she contended that democratic societies are less likely to make war than non-democratic societies. “What I’m suggesting to you is that if we care about world peace, we need to think about pushing back against the fraying of democracies at home. This is an international project. There are international costs to domestic backsliding, and that’s something we need to keep in mind.” She argued that democracy is not merely a desirable political system, but one necessary to maintain a global order of peace.

The lecture concluded by opening up to questions from the audience. The night ended around 8:20 p.m.

Featured image: Ethan Cooper’27

Author


Comments

Leave a Reply