Who makes decisions at this school? I can tell you right now that it is not students. Not only do students not make decisions at this school, but they barely get told about the decisions that do get made. Here are just some examples of students not being involved in decisions at this college:
Food Pantry
Beloit College has over 900 students and hundreds more staff and faculty, yet the decision to cut the food pantry was made by two people, one of whom just started working here again after a four-year absence. Were students consulted about the closing of the pantry? Were students even officially told that it was closing, or where to receive similar services? No, they weren’t.
One of the biggest given reasons for the cut was that 93.8% of on-campus students have a meal plan. That figure only accounts for about 760 students on-campus, not the over 900 total students. Accounting for study-abroad and other data intricacies, there are roughly 175 students not on a meal plan. Do students living off-campus not need access to food? Were they asked?
What if we took the 93.8% at face value? What that doesn’t account for is that 25% (178) of students on meal plans are on the Gold Plan (7 swipes a week). Many choose that plan due to the over $1,500 in savings it provides, and that percentage may go up next year, because of the 15% meal plan increase for 27-28. Those students do not have full access to dining services. Were those students talked to? At most, according to food staff workers about 63% (450) of students on meal plans even swipe in for dinner every day. Was there any meaningful effort placed in trying to figure out the actual meal plan and timing issues affecting access for 40% of meal plan holders, ranging from hours of service, to the nearly two-week food service closure during winter break?All of this does not point to a “researched” decision.
Some points I would like to make here as someone who has used food pantries and been food insecure. I never want to hear the term “cost-ineffective” as a reason to describe decreasing food access. The “need” of a pantry is shown by the fact that food is taken, and food was consistently taken from this pantry. It is actually crazy that Beloit College has money to pay Eric Boynton over $300,000 and then has the audacity to even mention cost as a reason for the decrease in food access.
Cost and Direction of the School
Let’s talk about decisions made at an even higher level: The Board of Trustees. At their October meeting, they voted to increase the cost of attendance by 3.9% and to approve the School of Health Sciences Graduate Programs. What is important to note is that this 30-member body doesn’t represent the college very well.
There was no student representation at those meetings. While there has never been student voting power, in previous years, there was student representation on all but two BOT committees. I was one of the student representatives, but my term ended, and there have been no signs of new student representation taking place. There have already been very consequential decisions made in the one BOT meeting that has had no student representation; let’s not allow it to be more.
Pizza Oven
Here is a very acute example. In a Nov. 10 Round Table article about the new pizza oven on campus, we learned some things about decision-making priorities. The Associate Vice President of Faculties, Nate Osterberger, implied that the pizza oven, which cost $20,000, came from the student-driven Residential Experience Advisory Committee.
REAC wasn’t even introduced to the student body until a Sep. 10 information session, and the interest form to become a member did not go out until Sep. 28. According to Meghan Koning’27, one of the REAC representatives, the first REAC meeting didn’t take place until early November. Construction on the pizza oven began when students were moving in, in late August, and construction was finished in October, which indicates that students were not a part of the consultation process of this new construction. Further, students have yet to receive any official communication about the pizza oven, and why that much money was spent on it when there are other active student concerns with housing.
Doing Better
If you were to walk into an economics or business classroom on campus, you might learn about the importance of stakeholder input. You may even hear about how this input is particularly important when decisions are risky, rushed, high-impact, etc. Why do we teach students about the importance of the stakeholder’s voice for the “outside world” and then throw it out the window for internal matters? It keeps happening: from changes in housing, cost increases, status of international students, food access, space planning, program development, construction, and more. Sometimes, students get an apology and commitment that “next time,” it will be better.
I would like a response from Beloit College’s leadership on why they think that is.
Featured image: Beloit Daily News



Leave a Reply